UPDATES & ANALYSIS
A New Fast Track for Certified Questions?
By Ryan Koopmans
Sometimes issues of state law come up in federal cases. When that happens, and when the state law is unclear, federal courts can certify the question to the state’s highest court, asking it to weigh in. This certification process stops the federal case until the state court rules, however, which can present problems for the litigants if the state court takes a long time to answer the certified question.
The justices of the Iowa Supreme Court appear to understand this. Indeed, based on their decisions in Iowa Right to Life Committee, Inc. v. Tooker and Oyens Feed & Supply, Inc. v. Primebank, they’re working to speed up the certification process. The Court issued its opinion in Iowa Right to Life just 183 days after the federal court certified the question, its opinion in Oyens Feed only 270 days after the federal court sought its guidance. And both decisions—authored by Justices Mansfield and Waterman respectively— came within three weeks of oral argument. That’s fast.
And much faster than the Court moved in the past. From January 2001 to December 29, 2011, the Court issued seven decisions in which it answered certified questions from a federal court. On average, those decisions took 498 days from the date that the federal court certified the question. (A chart with relevant dates appears after the jump.)
The Iowa Supreme Court’s likely prize for answering the Right to Life and Oyens Feed questions so quickly: more certified questions.
Certified Questions 2001-2011
FEATURED POSTS
Divided Iowa Supreme Court upholds state law governing restoration of firearms rights
In its first decision addressing a 2022 constitutional amendment that for the first time recognizes a “fundamental” right to bear arms in the Iowa Constitution, a divided Iowa Supreme Court affirmed the Pottawattamie District Court’s ruling denying an Iowa man’s bid to have his firearms rights restored after those rights had been revoked.
Iowa Supreme Court to hear arguments in one case in Marshalltown Nov. 19
The Iowa Supreme Court will hear oral arguments Nov. 19 in an evening session in Marshalltown in a case that involves the legality of a home search under the Iowa Constitution.
The Nov. 19 argument in Marshalltown is one in a series of court sessions held outside of the Judicial Branch Building in Des Moines to give Iowa …
Malpractice case resulting in $97 million verdict sent back for a new trial by Iowa Supreme Court
A manufacturer’s written package insert regarding the use of an obstetrical vacuum used to deliver a baby born with brain damage contained hearsay that should not have been allowed into evidence in a medical malpractice trial that resulted in a $97 million jury verdict, the Iowa Supreme Court held in a unanimous ruling issued Nov. 8.
Iowa Court of Appeals October 2024 Published Opinion Roundup
The Iowa Court of Appeals selects certain opinions for publication in the Northwestern Reporter. In October, the Court of Appeals selected four opinions for publication. Following are summaries of those opinions.
EDITORIAL TEAM
ABOUT
On Brief: Iowa’s Appellate Blog is devoted to appellate litigation with a focus on the Iowa Supreme Court, the Iowa Court of Appeals, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.