UPDATES & ANALYSIS

8.05

No Punitive Damages After Death

by Ryan Koopmans | August 5, 2011

By Ryan Koopmans

The Iowa Supreme Court reaffirmed today the rule that punitive damages do not follow you to the grave.  Writing for a majority of the Court in The Estate of Johnny Vajgrt v. Bill Ernst, Inc., Justice Mansfield explained that because “the role of punitive damages is punitive, rather than compensatory, such damages should not be awarded when the person to be punished has died.”  While it is true that Iowa law provides that all “causes of action” survive death, the Court ruled that punitive damages “do not constitute a ‘cause of action.’”

Justice Wiggins issued a short concurring opinion (joined by Justice Appel).  He did not find the basis behind the no-punitive-damages-after-death rule to be particularly persuasive, but nevertheless agreed to reaffirm the rule because the legislature had seemingly approved it by passing punitive damages legislation without overruling the Court’s precedents on the issue.

Justice Hecht dissented.  In his view, allowing punitive damage claims to go forward after death serves two purposes: (1) retribution, and (2) deterrence.  Tortfeasors will be deterred, according to Justice Hecht, by the prospect that their innocent beneficiaries will be harmed by any future punitive damages award against the estate.

The opinions are here.   And the Des Moines Register’s coverage of the decision is here.

SHARE

Tags:

FEATURED POSTS

Iowa Supreme Court deadlocks on specifics required for liability waivers

When Dubuque police officer Katherine Avenarius accidentally shot herself in the leg while attending an Iowa Law Enforcement Academy firearms instructor school, she sued the academy claiming her injury was the result of an instructor’s advice on how to handle her firearm that contradicted how she had previously been trained. The State, which operates the academy, argued Avenarius signed a “clear and unequivocal” waiver and release of liability.

Iowa Supreme Court upholds minimum prison term for juvenile convicted of murder

The Iowa Supreme Court upheld a 35-year minimum prison sentence for a Fairfield juvenile who pleaded guilty to first degree murder for the death of his high school Spanish teacher. In its unanimous decision, the Court rejected the defendant’s argument that, under the Iowa Constitution, the State must present expert testimony showing a minimum sentence is necessary for a juvenile offender.

EDITORIAL TEAM

ABOUT

On Brief: Iowa’s Appellate Blog is devoted to appellate litigation with a focus on the Iowa Supreme Court, the Iowa Court of Appeals, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.

RELATED BLOGS

Related Links

ARCHIVES