The Iowa Supreme Court ruled Friday that a warrantless breath test used to prosecute Dale Pettijohn for operating a boat while intoxicated violated Article I, section 8 of the Iowa Constitution, the state equivalent of the U.S. Constitution’s Fourth Amendment that prohibits unreasonable searches and…
ARCHIVE
A splintered Iowa Supreme Court reverses $1.4 million employment judgment
The Iowa Supreme Court on June 23 reversed a $1.4 million sexual harassment jury verdict against a northeast Iowa ethanol plant and ordered a new trial. While the justices unanimously agreed that the trial judge’s instructions to the jury were flawed, they were divided into…
Supreme Court’s lottery ruling a lesson for Iowa law enforcement
Law enforcement authorities who dilly-dally in investigating crimes face the prospect of losing at trial because the statute of limitations clock has run out, the Iowa Supreme ruled Friday. The Court threw out the 2015 conviction of Eddie Tipton, a former Multistate Lottery Association security…
Juvenile sentencing ruling exposes deep fissure on Iowa Supreme Court
Mandatory minimum criminal sentences for juvenile offenders do not always violate the Iowa Constitution but they should be short and uncommon, the Iowa Supreme Court ruled on Friday. The decision in State v. Roby is the latest in a series of decisions regarding the constitutionality…
Deer quarantine law doesn’t extend to hunting preserves, Iowa Supreme Court rules
The Iowa Department of Natural Resources went too far when it quarantined a 330-acre hunting preserve to prevent the spread of a deer disease, the Iowa Supreme Court ruled Friday. But the Court held that the quarantine did not amount to a government “taking” of…
FEATURED POSTS
Iowa Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in eight appeals Wednesday and Thursday
The Iowa Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in eight appeals Wednesday and Thursday. Six other cases will be submitted to the Court this week without oral argument. The arguments will be in the Supreme Court courtroom with the option of participating remotely. Livestreamed videos…
Iowa Supreme Court selects Chief Justice Susan Christensen for a second term
Chief Justice Susan Christensen has been selected by the members of the Iowa Supreme Court for a second term, the Judicial Branch announced Jan. 8. At 10 a.m. Wednesday, Christensen will deliver the Condition of the Judiciary address to a joint session of the Iowa…
Iowa Supreme Court: Tort Claims Act governs excessive-force claims under the state Constitution
A plaintiff with a claim under the Iowa Constitution for damages against the State or its employee must follow the procedures prescribed by the Iowa Tort Claims Act, including the Act’s exclusion of punitive damages, the Iowa Supreme Court said in a ruling handed down…
Justice Matthew McDermott traces his route to the Iowa Supreme Court in podcast interview
In a new “In the Balance” podcast, Justice Matthew McDermott, the newest member of the Iowa Supreme Court, talks about growing up in Carroll, Iowa, attending law school in California, and his path from a trial lawyer to the pinnacle of Iowa’s judiciary. The podcast,…
EDITORIAL TEAM
ABOUT
On Brief: Iowa’s Appellate Blog is devoted to appellate litigation with a focus on the Iowa Supreme Court, the Iowa Court of Appeals, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.