UPDATES & ANALYSIS
Court of Appeals Judge David May elevated to Iowa Supreme Court by Governor Reynolds
Judge David May, who describes himself as a “regular person” who received “extraordinary blessings,” has risen to the pinnacle of the Iowa judicial system with his appointment to the Iowa Supreme Court July 27 by Gov. Kim Reynolds.
Judge May’s self description can be found in his application to the State Judicial Nominating Commission, who advanced his nomination to the governor after interviews with all five applicants for the opening created by the retirement of Justice Brent Appel.
A native of what he describes as a medium-size town in northeast Missouri, Judge May came to Iowa where he graduated with high honors from Drake Law School and worked in private practice for the Hawkins & Norris law firm and later for Bradshaw, Fowler, Proctor & Fairgrave before becoming a trial judge in Polk County in 2016. Judge May was appointed by Governor Reynolds to the Iowa Court of Appeals in 2019.
In his 15 years at the Bradshaw firm, Judge May focused largely on civil litigation and insurance coverage work, including claims involving suspected arson and fraud.
In response to a question on the judicial application about significant legal matters he worked on, Judge May listed two cases involving insurance issues. A third case he cited was tried in federal court, initially brought by an inmate at the Fort Madison State Penitentiary representing himself before May was appointed pro bono counsel for the plaintiff. The inmate alleged his constitutional rights were violated by prison staff.
Although U.S. District Judge James Gritzner ultimately ruled against his client, Judge May said the experience changed his perspective on the corrections system.
“It opened my eyes to challenges faced by both by corrections staff and by prisoners,” he wrote. “It also reinforced the importance of our judicial system as a safeguard against violation of constitutional rights.”
Judge May, who lives in Polk City, is married with two young-adult children.
FEATURED POSTS
State immunity bars wrongful imprisonment claim for money damages, Iowa Supreme Court holds
Eugene Sikora sued the State of Iowa and the Iowa Corrections Director seeking money damages claiming he was wrongly imprisoned for about five months longer than the law allowed due to a miscalculation by the Department of Corrections. The Iowa Supreme Court, in a 4-3 decision, held that Sikora’s claim for money damages f …
Court finds for Corteva on claims of discrimination and retaliation by former employee
The Iowa Supreme Court reversed the Iowa Court of Appeals’ decision in part in McClure v. E. I. du Pont de Nemours & Co., a case regarding a former Corteva Agriscience (“Corteva”) employee’s termination and the employee’s allegations of discrimination and retaliation against Corteva.
Iowa Supreme Court approves warrantless search of fanny pack after it was removed by suspect
A police officer legally searched a fanny pack after a suspect had removed it and handed it to a companion, the Iowa Supreme Court held in a June 20 decision, because the fanny pack was removed at the moment the officer was attempting to handcuff and arrest the suspect.
Dismissal of claims brought by estates of women killed in low-head dam drowning was improper, Iowa Supreme Court concludes
In Estate of Kahn v. City of Clermont, the Iowa Supreme Court reversed the district court’s decision to dismiss two estates’ claims for premises liability and negligence brought against the City of Clermont, Fayette County Conservation Board, Fayette County, and the State of Iowa.
EDITORIAL TEAM
ABOUT
On Brief: Iowa’s Appellate Blog is devoted to appellate litigation with a focus on the Iowa Supreme Court, the Iowa Court of Appeals, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.