IOWA SUPREME COURT CASES IN THE PIPELINE

2021-2022 TERM // 2022-2023 TERM

Argued Wednesday, March 23, 2022

Case No.	*Case Name*	Brief
20-1346	Rodrigo Adolpho Amaya v. State Public Defender	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief State of Iowa Amicus Curiae Brief
21-0652	Garrison v. New Fashion Pork LLP et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Amicus Curiae Brief

Argued February 22, 2022

Case No.	Case Name	Brief
20-1035	James C. Larew v. Hope Law Firm, P.L.C., et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Appellee Reply Brief

Argued January 20, 2022

Case No.	Case Name	Brief
20-1323	Site A Landowners et al. v. South Cent. Reg’l Airport Agency, et al.	Landowers Brief Landowners Reply Brief Mahaska Brief Mahaska Reply Brief Appellee Brief Appellee Reply Brief

Argued December 14, 2021

Case No.	*Case Name*	Brief
20-1454	Ronald Hampton v. Martin Marietta Materials, Inc. et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief

Argued November 17, 2021

Case No.	Case Name	Brief
19-1689	Great Western Bank v. Clement	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Appellee Reply Brief Amicus Curiae Brief
19-1681	Willard B. McNaughton v. Chartier, et al.	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Chartiers Appellee Brief Lawton Appellee Brief

Argued September 16, 2021

Case No.	Case Name	Brief
19-0945	State of Iowa v. Stanley Liggins	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief

Case No.	*Case Name*	Brief	Supreme Court Opinion
20-0359	State v. Walter Lee Miller, Jr.	Application for Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1852	Beverage, et al. v. ALCOA, Inc., et al.	Application for Further Review Taylor Insulation Resistance to Further Review Arconic Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Taylor Insulation Brief Arconic Brief Amicus Curae Brief	Opinion
19-2086	Hoffman and Hoffman Innovations d/b/a DIY Autotune v. Clark and Realtuners, LLC	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0963	Carreras et al. v. Iowa Dep’t of Transp., Motor Vehicle Div.	Application for Further Review Resistan ce to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0972	Borst Brothers Const., Inc. v. Thomas Dostal Developers, Inc.	Application for Further Review Borst Resistance to Further Review Finance Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Borst Appellee Brief Kelly Concrete Appellee Brief Thomas Dostal Dev. Appellee Brief Thomas Dostal Dev. Appellee Reply Brief	Opinion
21-0856	Planned Parenthood of the Hearthland, Inc., et al. v. Reynolds ex rel. State of Iowa and Iowa Board of Medicine	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief ICADV and ICASA Amicus Curiae Brief Kirkwood Inst. and Members of 89th Gen. Assem. of IA Amicus Curiae Brief League of Women Voters of IA Amicus Curiae Brief Medical Assoc. Amicus Curiae Brief Univ. of Iowa and Drake Univ. Law Prof. Amicus Curiae Brief IA Legislature Members Amicus Curiae Brief IA State Legislators Amicus Curiae Brief IA State Senators Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
19-1917	James Elvin Dorsey v. State of Iowa	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0396	Fernando Sandoval v. State of Iowa	Appellant Brief Appe llant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0769	American Home Assurance v. Liberty Mutual Fire Ins. Co.	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1148	Andrew Lennette, et al. v. State of Iowa, et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1647	State of Iowa v. Erica Lyne West Vangen	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0679	Amanda deSousa f/k/a Amanda Johnston v. Iowa Realty Co., Inc.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
20-0837	Sioux City Truck Sales, Inc. v. Iowa Dep’t of Transportation, et al.	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0841	Tripp v. Scott Emergency Commc’n, et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-1472	In the Interest of K.D. and K.D., Minor Children	Court of Appeals Opinion	Opinion
19-0453	State of Iowa v. Ethan L. Davis	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0098	Meade v. Christie, et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
21-0664	State of Iowa v. Pamela Mildred Middlekauff	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0076	In re Marriage of Hutchinson	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0280	State of Iowa v. Jordan McKim Crawford	Application for Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1595	State of Iowa v. Earnest Jones Hunt, Jr.	Application for Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1037	Estate of Susan Farrell, et al. v. State of Iowa, et al.	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1582	Rausch v. City of Marion	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-2075	State of Iowa v. Mark Bernard Retterath	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0257	State of Iowa v. Korki Ricoh Wilbourn	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0814	Union Pac. R.R. Co. et al. v. Drainage Dist. 67 Bd. of Trustees, et al.	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0227	Rand v. Security Nat’l Corp.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
21-0953	Little v. Davis, et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0195	Danielle Putman v. Walther & Walther	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Application Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0479	ACC Holdings, LLC v. Todd Rooney	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0623	Jesse’s Embers, LLC v. Western Agric. Ins. Co.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0374	Wakonda Club v. Selective Ins. Co. of America	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1568	State of Iowa v. Brent Alan Hauge	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1228	Struck v. Mercy Health Services-Iowa Corp. a/k/a Mercy Medical Center-Sioux City, et al.	Application for Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Dean, Okine, Middleton Appellee Brief Mercy Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1124	Estate of Berry v. Grossman, et al.	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1857	State of Iowa v. Kha Len Richard Price-Williams	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
22-0618	Kim Schmett & Leanne Pellett v. State Objections Panel and Abby for Iowa	State Objections Panel Appellant Brief Abby for Iowa Intervenor Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0950	State of Iowa v. Caesar Charles Davison	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0324	In re the Interest of Z.K., Minor Child	Court of Appeals Opinion	Opinion
20-0484	Vroegh v. Iowa Dep’t of Corections, et al., and Wellmark, Inc.	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief Appellee Reply Brief Cross-Appellee Wellmark Brief	Opinion
20-1686	State of Iowa v. Tiffany Sue McCalley	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0144	State of Iowa v. Peter Leroy Veal	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
21-0158	State of Iowa v. Antoine Tyree Williams	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0760	Deng v. Farmland Foods, Inc., et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief IA Fed of Labor Amicus Curiae Brief LULAC Amicus Curiae Brief Workers’ Comp Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
21-0777	Chavez v. MS Technology LLC, et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief IA Federation of Labor Amicus Curiae Brief LULAC IA Amicus Curiae Brief Workers’ Comp Core Group Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
19-1981	State of Iowa v. Annette Dee Cahill	Application for Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1052	State of Iowa v. Patrick Bracy	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1506	State of Iowa v. Randy Allen Crawford	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0090	In re the Marriage of Pazhoor	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0156	State of Iowa v. Shane Michael Davis	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0464	State of Iowa v. Justice Mathis	Application for Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0879	Carlson v. Second Succession, LLC, et al.	Application for Further Review Second Succession Resistance to Further Review Jones Resistance to Further Review Appellant Brief Second Succession Brief Jones Brief	Opinion
21-0243	In the Interest of T.F. and T.F., Minor Children	Court of Appeals Opinion	Opinion
19-1228	State of Iowa v. Dantreon Levon Newman	Application for Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1983	Mengwasser v. Comito, et al.	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0817	Goche v. WMG, L.C.	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Appellee Reply Brief	Opinion
20-0192	State of Iowa v. Kevin Jon Thoren	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1571	State of Iowa v. Timothy Michael Basquin	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1300	State of Iowa v. Myranda Marie Rincon	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1393	State of Iowa v. Yale Stevens	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1423	State of Iowa v. Brianna Sue Watson	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1510	Riley Drive Entertainment I, Inc., et al. v. Reynolds, et al.	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-0569	In the Interest of L.B., Minor Child	Court of Appeals Opinion	Opinion
20-0630	State of Iowa v. Randall Lee Hurlburt	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0617	State of Iowa v. Kenneth Lee Lilly	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief NAACP Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
20-1530	State of Iowa v. Veil Jacoby Jackson-Douglass	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1878	State of Iowa v. Kurt Allen Kraai	Application for Further Review – IA Courts of Appeal Decision Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0401	State of Iowa v. Hollis Bear	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief US Amicus Curiae Brief Sac & Fox Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
20-0409	State of Iowa v. Christopher Lee Cungtion, Jr.	Appellant Brief Appellant Supplemental Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief US Amicus Curiae Brief Sac & Fox Tribe Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
20-1244	State of Iowa v. George Davis	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1616	State of Iowa v. Kourtney Shontez Hall	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-2137	McGrew v. Otoadese	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1000	State of Iowa v. Kelvin Plain, Sr.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
20-0371	State of Iowa v. Edna Jean Wilson	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1034	In the Matter of the Guardianship of L.Y.	Court of Appeals Opinion	Opinion
20-0030	State of Latrice L. Lacey	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0657	Klein v. Iowa Public Information Board, et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Burlington Police Dep’t Appellee Brief Iowa Public Info Appellee Brief Dep’t of Safety Waiver Brief	Opinion
21-0095	Hills & Dales Child Development Center v. Iowa Dep’t of Education, et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0902	Polk County Assessor Randy Ripperger v. Iowa Public Information Board	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-0997	Askvig v. Snap-On Logistics Co.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1837	Anna Sothman v. State of Iowa	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-0971	State of Iowa v. Michael James Jones	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Application Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1689	Wayne Joseph Mlady v. Sue Ann Dougan	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Amicus Curiae Brief Response to Amicus Brief	Opinion
21-0540	In the Intrest of W.T., Minor Child	Court of Appeals Opinion	Opinion
20-0375	Bomgaars, et al. v. State of Iowa	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Amicus Curiae Brief	Opinion
19-0969	Marriage of Miller and Miller	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Application Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief Appellee Reply Brief	Opinion
19-1613	State of Iowa v. Michael D. Montgomery	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
20-1429	Domenico Calcaterra v. Iowa Board of Medicine	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1067	State of Iowa v. Jake Skahill	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-1509	State of Iowa v. Jameesha Renae Allen	Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Application Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
19-2112	State of Iowa v. James Paul Vandermark	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion
21-3014	In re Interest of D.M., Minor Child	Court of Appeals Opinion	Opinion
19-0283	State of Iowa v. Alan James Kuuttila	Application for Further Review Appellant Brief Appellee Brief	Opinion

Case No.	Case Name	Briefs
20-1150	State of Iowa v. Jerry Lynn Burns	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief ACLU Amicus Curiae Brief
21-0079	State of Iowa v. Cameron James Hess	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief
21-1072	Martin v. Tovar et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief
21-0744	State of Iowa v. Ronald James Brimmer	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief
21-0859	Dickey, et al. v. Hoff, et al.	Appellant Brief Hoff Appellee Brief Jennie Edmundson Hospital Appellee Brief Lancaster CSD Appellee Brief
21-1211	State of Iowa v. Benjamin G. Trane	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief
21-0411	Arzel Jones v. State of Iowa	Appellant Brief Appellee Brief
21-0649	Benda v. Iowa Horsemen’s Benevolent & Protective Ass’n	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Prairie Meadows Appellee Brief Horsemens Intervenor Brief Thoroughbred Breeders Intervenor Brief
21-0980	Martinez, et al. v. State of Iowa	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief
21-0999	Save Our Stadiums, et al. v. Des Moines Indep. Sch. Dist., et al.	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief
21-1146	State of Iowa v. John Eddie Hanes, III	Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief

Case No.	Case Name	Briefs
21-0067	Braaksma v. Bd. of Sibley-Ocheyedan CSD	Application for Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief
20-0786	James Farnsworth II v. State of Iowa	Appellant Application for Further Review Appellee Application for Further Review Resistance to Further Review Court of Appeals Opinion Appellant Brief Appellant Reply Brief Appellee Brief

Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals affirms dismissal of former City of Cedar Falls employee’s claims against the city

Iowa Supreme Court’s splintered abortion ruling: Four opinions covering 182 pages

Was a real estate agent liable when a prospective buyer fell on an icy driveway? The Iowa Supreme Court says no

Iowa Supreme Court declines to extend juvenile sentencing protections to young adults in two cases

APPELLATE CALENDAR

EDITORIAL TEAM

ABOUT

On Brief: Iowa’s Appellate Blog is devoted to appellate litigation with a focus on the Iowa Supreme Court, the Iowa Court of Appeals, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.

IOWA SUPREME COURT CASES IN THE PIPELINE

2021-2022 TERM // 2022-2023 TERM

Argued Wednesday, March 23, 2022

Argued February 22, 2022

Argued January 20, 2022

Argued December 14, 2021

Argued November 17, 2021

Argued September 16, 2021

FEATURED POSTS

Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals affirms dismissal of former City of Cedar Falls employee’s claims against the city

Iowa Supreme Court’s splintered abortion ruling: Four opinions covering 182 pages

Was a real estate agent liable when a prospective buyer fell on an icy driveway? The Iowa Supreme Court says no

Iowa Supreme Court declines to extend juvenile sentencing protections to young adults in two cases

APPELLATE CALENDAR

EDITORIAL TEAM

ABOUT

RELATED BLOGS

Related Links

ARCHIVES

Practice areas

News & Insights

Resources